Barbratimeless
A Personal Retrospective on the Career of Barbra Streisand

[Barbra, Live]   [Past Features]   [Streisand History]   [Reviews]   [Where Are They Now?]   [Home]

Feature: Fanny Sings "Funny Girl"
June 2006

The Original Brice Renditions

Barbra owes much of her early success to her universally acclaimed portrayals of Fanny Brice on Broadway and in the movies. Fanny was as big a star in her time as Barbra is in ours, and these two funny girls have a lot in common musically. Though none of Fanny Brice's signature songs were included in the Broadway version of "Funny Girl," Barbra had the chance to sing three of Brice's signature songs for the film.

In the Ziegfeld Follies of 1921, Fanny Brice debuted the ballad "My Man" and quickly established it as her signature song. Brice later released "My Man" on Victor records and the recording became a number 1 hit in 1922. In 1936, Brice also performed the number in the film, "The Great Ziegfeld." Her rendition of "My Man" was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.

"Second Hand Rose" was another of Brice's signature songs. It was also performed in the Ziegfeld Follies of 1921.

In 1928, Fanny Brice introduced the song "I'd Rather Be Blue" in the film, "My Man." The song was written by Billy Rose and Fred Fisher.


"Funny Girl": Fact or Fiction?

It has been said that Ray Stark's original intention was to create an entertainment piece with "Funny Girl" and indeed that was the case. However, much of what is portrayed in "Funny Girl" is not exactly as it happened in real life. Liberties were taken with several of the facts surrounding the life of Fanny Brice and Nick Arnstein in an effort to romanticize the story line. Here are just a few tidbits about the real Fanny Brice that you did not learn from "Funny Girl."

  • Nick Arnstein was Fanny's second husband. Her first marriage was to Frank White, a barber. They were divorced in short order.

  • Fanny Brice was born Fanny Borach. Brice was her assumed stage name.

  • Fanny came from a wealthy background. Her parents owned several profitable saloons in New Jersey. They lived on fashionable Beekman Place in Manhattan, had servants, and traveled the world.

  • Fanny debuted at Keeney's burlesque hall in Brooklyn as a solo performer, not a member of the chorus. She did not meet Nick Arnstein there. They met in Baltimore in 1912 while he was still married to another woman.

  • Nick Arnstein's transgressions with the law were a lot more serious than what was depicted in the film. He used several aliases to cover up his international criminal record. He had served time in Sing Sing prison well before he and Fanny were married, so she knew his history in advance of tying the knot. They divorced in 1927.

  • Fanny and Nick had two children.

  • Fanny was good friends with Irving Berlin, and it was with his help that Fanny was able to break into show business.

  • Fanny Brice never performed in a bride number.

  • The Brice-Ziegfeld relationship was a professional one and she always bowed to his creative instincts.

  • Fanny Brice later recorded for Columbia Records.

source: Funny Girl Debunked: Fanny Brice Facts by John Kenrick