Main Menu

HOME PAGE
Barbra, Live!
Features
News
Editorials
Reviews
Photo Galleries
Clippings
On Location
People
Streisand History
Visit Our Friends
E-Mail

 

See Also

Barbra / Gypsy Rumor Goes Viral
The Barbra Connection:
Gypsy
Gypsy-Mania
The Barbra Connection:
West Side Story
The Barbra Connection:
Anyone Can Whistle
The Way We Were (review)
Katie: Controversial, and a Classic
On Location: Erasmus Hall
Miss Marmelstein, Miss Marmelstein
Remembering Theoni V. Aldredge
Some People!

 

Arthur Laurents

People We Remember

   

Director, Writer
Legendary director and writer Arthur Laurents passed away at his home in New York.
He was 93.
 

Barbra remembered Arthur Laurents with the following statement:

"Arthur and I go way back to 'I Can Get It For You Wholesale' in 1962. Then we did 'The Way We Were' in 1973 and we were about to do 'Gypsy' together. He created people you care about because he cared about people. I spoke to him a few weeks ago and he sounded so strong, as always. He was lucky to have lived a full and creative life up 'til the very end. I’ll miss working with him again."
   

Wrote "The Way We Were" and Directed "Wholesale"

May 5, 2011
The literary and entertainment communities are mourning the loss of Arthur Laurents, prolific author of "West Side Story," "Gypsy" and "The Way We Were." According to the New York Times, Laurents passed away at his home in Manhattan earlier this evening following a bout with pneumonia. He was 93. At 8 PM on May 6, the lights on Broadway will dim in tribute to the Brooklyn born native and Erasmus Hall graduate.

In 1962, Laurents hired Barbra to play Miss Marmelstein in "I Can Get It For You Wholesale," a show he was directing. He provided Barbra Streisand with her first opportunity to perform on a Broadway stage.

Barbra also appeared in "The Way We Were," a 1973 film written by Laurents that was adapted from his best selling novel. She received an Oscar nomination for her performance.

Both projects were monumental turning points in Barbra's career.
 


Hollywood, The Blacklist and "The Way We Were"
Arthur Laurents wrote some of Hollywood's most memorable screenplays including "The Turning Point," Alfred Hitchcock's "Rope," "Anastasia" and, of course, the film versions of both "Gypsy" and "West Side Story."

When it came time to adapt "The Way We Were" for the screen, Laurents, director Sydney Pollack and producer Ray Stark were at odds. They didn't like Laurent's early screenplay drafts, so much in fact that Laurents was actually fired as the screenwriter.

Stark was unhappy with Laurents' early drafts which apparently placed more emphasis on the political aspects of the story and less on the romance. Those hired to replace Laurents didn't fare any better. Stark and Pollack pleaded with Laurents to return, which he did at a hefty increase in compensation. His final screenplay managed to find an acceptable balance of both themes.

Remembering David Rayfiel

(UPDATE: June 22, 2011) -
One of the writers hired by Sydney Pollack to to help "fix" Arthur Laurents' original "Way We Were" screenplay was David Rayfiel. He passed away on June 22, at the age of 87.

Rayfiel, along with fellow screenwriters Daltom Trumbo and Francis Ford Coppola helped turn Laurents' overly political screenplay into one that focused more on the romantic theme of the story. Perhaps at the insistence of Arthur Laurents, the contributions of Rayfiel, Trumbo and Coppola were uncredited.

Rayfiel's talents were employed several times by Sydney Pollack, particularly on films that starred Robert Redford. In addition to "The Way We Were," Rayfiel helped fashion scripts for "Out of Africa" and "Three Days of the Condor." Redford once called him "the unsung hero of almost every picture Sydney Pollack and I have made together."

David Rayfiel's first wife was actress Maureen Stapleton, one of Barbra Streisand's costars in the film "Nuts."

It's no wonder that Arthur Laurents wanted to play up the political subtext on "The Way We Were." It came from the author's' own personal experiences on the matter. Laurents was one of the many Hollywood writers who were blacklisted in the late 40s and early '50s. When one of his works was reviewed in "The Daily Worker," Laurents was called to Washington to testify before the House Un-American Activities Committee. Unlike some of his colleagues however, Laurents was able to rebound. The whole blacklist debacle had no lasting effect on his career.

Laurents wrote about "The Way We Were" at length in his 2000 autobiography, "Original Story." In an interesting anecdote, Laurents discusses the reason why he felt Barbra didn't win the Best Actress Oscar:

"Katie Morosky was an Oscar-winning role. What could have guaranteed Barbra's winning was a long, heart-breaking telephone call. Instead, I think it cost her the Oscar. Almost from the first word, there was the fixed speech; it came and went, taking reality with it ... How I wished I could have directed her in that phone call! There was no reason for her to hide her face; Barbra Streisand understood rejection. What she needed was help from someone who understood her; then the Oscar she wanted would have been hers."
 



Bradway and "Wholesale"

Arthur Laurents was a six time Tony nominee and two time winner. He won his Tonys for directing the original production of "La Cage aux Folles" in 1984 and for writing the musical "Hallelujah Baby!" in 1968.

Laurents was the author of not one, but two theatrical masterpieces. He wrote both "Gypsy" in 1959 and "West Side Story" in 1957 - literary accomplishments that will forever insure his place as one of the greatest authors of American theatre.

Laurents was working right 'till the very end. He directed a critically acclaimed Broadway revival of "West Side Story" that closed this past January. His final production of "West Side Story" was nominated for three Tonys.

As for "Gypsy," many consider Laurent's adaptation of the Gypsy Rose Lee memoir to be the quintessential Broadway musical. It was first produced in 1959 as a star vehicle for Ethel Merman. With lyrics by Steven Sondheim and music by Jule Styne, "Gypsy" received eight Tony nominations but came up empty handed on award night. Since then, "Gypsy" has more than made up for that initial Tony snub. Collectively, its four subsequent Broadway revivals racked up 6 Tony wins, including Best Actress trophies for Angela Lansbury (1975), Tyne Daly (1990) and Patti LuPone (2008).

When Laurents was hired to direct "I Can Get It For You Wholesale" in 1962, he put out a casting call for the bit part of a middle aged spinster secretary named Miss Marmelstein. Nineteen year old Barbra Streisand answered the call. After a number of callbacks, not only was Barbra hired, but the role was rewritten and expanded to include several musical numbers for her to perform. In "Original Story," Laurents recalls that first Streisand audition:

"Eight bars into her first song, I knew she had to be in the show. She began with a comedy number from an Off-Broadway review she'd been in, then 'Sleepin' Bee' followed by 'Soon It's Gonna Rain.' I would have had her sing every song she knew just to sit back and revel in the glory of that voice."


Arthur Laurents (left) with Barbra and the cast of
"I Can Get It For You Wholesale"

Barbra was a sensation as Miss Marmelstein. She was arguably the singular reason such a dark and tedious musical about the garment trade was able to last on Broadway for as long as it did.

When "Wholesale" closed (after 300 performances), Laurents didn't want to let go of Barbra. He wanted her to appear in his next musical called "Anyone Can Whistle." Laurents wrote and directed the show. It was also the first musical for which Stephen Sondheim composed both music and lyrics. Laurents desperately wanted Barbra. Sondheim, on the other hand, was ambivalent about the possible casting decision. In the time it took for Sondheim to consider Barbra for what was probably just a secondary role in "Anyone Can Whistle," Barbra had signed with Ray Stark to star in "Funny Girl."  "Anyone Can Whistle" was one of 1964's monumental flops. "Funny Girl" on the other hand, catapulted Barbra Streisand into theatrical stardom.

Laurents was in the throws of trying to bring Barbra Streisand back to the world of musical comedy when he passed away. It was his hope that Barbra would tackle the lead in a film remake of "Gypsy." For a time, Laurents and Sondheim once again seemed at odds about a casting decision involving Barbra Streisand (shades of 1964).

Fortunately, it does appear that Barbra will star in the film remake of "Gypsy." It would be her ultimate tribute to the man who gave her that first big break on Broadway.